Browse By Show: 

Shonda Rhimes Visits Chandra Wilson, "Chicago" Comments (Page 2)

34 Comments

« Previous
1 2
  1. Zephyr Says:

    "chelsea",
    I mentioned the real name thing for a reason that has obviously completely flown over your head, so don't worry about it.. (not trying to insult you, I just don’t think you understood my point)

    However, I did not "belittle" your opinion by disagreeing with it. If I disagree with you I'm not belittling you, so again, I don't think you even understood what I meant. Belittling someone is a way of criticizing them or putting them down. Disagreeing with you is an entirely different thing. The reason I said people were belittling MY opinion is because it's true: they said that my opinion was "cowardly and pathetic". It should be plain as day to you that there is no hypocrisy going on from my side. I am not the one who instigated a petty name calling argument based on me and others saying that we think Shonda looks creepy.(McCynic is the one I originally responded to) The entire reason I wrote what I wrote was because I have no tolerance for people attacking my opinion just because they disagree with it. Try re-reading the comments and it should be clear to you that if no one had accused anybody of being "cowardly and pathetic" just because they voiced an opinion, this argument would never have taken place. I'm not a hypocrite for defending myself or disagreeing with you. And you don't have to be a hypocrite either if you can accept that other people disagreeing with you does not warrant them being called "cowardly and pathetic". Think about it.

  2. chelsea Says:

    This is mchappy... I'm not scared to use my own name. By me using my own name does that help you know me any better? No. Who cares what people use as their name? That doesn't mean their opinions change just because their name is changed. You yourself could be lying about your own name.

    And you belittled my opinion because you didn't agree with it. Looks to me like there is hypocrisy going on on both sides.

  3. Simone Says:

    You know what? Shonda treated George like dirt because she didn't consider him hot.

    She judged him on his appearance, but we shouldn't?

    Why not?

    She always acted like the hot guys were somehow better than George and deserved .love more just because they looked hot.

    She got rid of the one likable character for it, so why should we not treat her the same way?

    George was beautiful inside. Shonda is ugly inside and outside.

    And I don't feel it's coward to say it.

  4. Zephyr Says:

    "What you say may be an opinion but it IS an opinion that is cowardly and pathetic"

    Excuse me? How does this statement make ANY sense whatsoever? By your reasoning, it doesn't matter what someone's opinion is, it is automatically "cowardly and pathetic"….unless the comment is something positive about Shonda. The reason I say this is because if I HADN'T said Shonda looked creepy, neither of you two would use that stupid "cowardly and pathetic" label. First of all, both you and McCynic are using online handles: you're not revealing who you truly are. This is the most obvious flaw in your argument. DON'T tell other people they are cowardly and pathetic just because they voice an opinion that you disagree with, especially if you‘re “hiding‘ behind a monitor too. Because that's ALL that's going on here. It does NOT matter what a person's opinion is, they have the right to say whatever they want. But the paradoxical belief that you are allowed to say whatever you want, while criticizing the comments that others make and putting labels on what they say is hypocrisy pure and simple. Again, just because you disagree with mine and other people's assertion that Shonda looks creepy, DOES NOT AT ALL mean that this assertion is "cowardly and pathetic". It is quite clear that some people here don't really reason through anything or think about what they are really trying to say before they make a comment. If we were all having this conversation in person, I wouldn’t say anything different, so again, stop deluding yourselves by thinking that people who voice an opinion that differs from yours is wrong. I have not tried to belittle other people's comments or pass judgment on others (besides stating that I think anybody who can't stomach another's opinion is deluded), but I cannot say the same for the people who are seemingly in love with Shonda and can't handle it when somebody says something about her that ISN'T sycophantic.

    “I am simply trying to say that maybe next time you can be nice in your opinions and think of other's feelings before you act.”

    The ultimate in hypocrisy! You yourself have not thought about your comments before you posted them, because you are trying to belittle my opinion, while at the same time saying “oh well it’s ok to have an opinion..” but adding onto it that I should “think about others feelings before I act”? Who do you think you are? Contradictions and hypocrisy seem to be the norm around here. Might I also add that you accused me of being “rude” to Shonda? I made a comment, I didn’t talk to her directly. “Opinions” are not something people need to be “nice” about. It doesn’t sound to me like you have any experience dealing with anybody who has an independent thought. You’re in for a rude awakening if you think you can hypocritically tell somebody their opinion is “cowardly and pathetic” just for stating what they think online. Besides the obvious fact that you yourself are not using your real name, it is downright laughable to say that someone’s opinion is cowardly and pathetic just because you disagree with it. Grow up.

  5. McHappy Says:

    I completely agree with McCynic! Why judge someone on their appearance?? You don't know that she looks "creepy" all the time. It's just a photograph... everyone takes bad photographs at times. I understand you were saying she looks creepy in this photo. But don't assume that she looks like that all the time.

    What you say may be an opinion but it IS an opinion that is cowardly and pathetic... which doesn't justify you being so rude towards her appearance. I realize that you have the right to say whatever you like and I'm not telling you that you can't do that. I am simply trying to say that maybe next time you can be nice in your opinions and think of other's feelings before you act.

  6. Eden Says:

    I don't even care about her weight. There are a lot of overweight people in this country, so it doesn't surprise me that the writer/producer of a TV show is overweight. What does surprise me is her treatment of the most REAL character on the show. The character that most of us, including her it seems, could identify with. Most GA fans wanted to see more of George last season...so his exiting storyline seems kinda harsh compared to IW/Burke's. Now the show is about a bunch of pretty faces and there is nobody funny or sweet like George. He really did bring so much to the show.

  7. charlotte Says:

    Oh. My. GOD.

    Shonda's face kind of shines!?!
    How many pounds of make up did she use?

  8. HG Says:

    Shonda and TR actually used to be very close. He was the only one who showed up at her birthday party in season 2, and there are plenty of photos of them beaming at each other.

    There's no clash of personality here. IW is her best friend, and she blamed TR for him leaving.
    Like many people, she let her friendship for IW blind her to much of his faults, homophobia, anger issues and arrogance, and TR, who is the sweetest guy in the world, got unfailry blamed for her by it.

    I find it weird that Shonda who's obviously not good-looking herself is so shallow.

    She judges George inferior because he's not conventionally good-looking. Is that how she judges herself too? Inferior because she doesn't look good? Or is it ok for women not to be hot, but guys absolutely have to be to have some value?

    Now everytime I look at her, all I see is the ordeal she put my sweet TR through, and I can,t even look at her!

  9. didi Says:

    Sondra seems to be one of those people (like me ) who is not photogenic and has a few extra lbs in weight. She's a busy lady and I think that her influence on GA this season will be to ink in what she sees happening to the characters, and then leave it to Betsy and the writers to fill the story out. I think Shonda will be looking forward to her next project with only 2 seasons of GA left. GA is fiction. In real life we don't always get on with everyone, amd there would seem to have been a clash of personalities here.

  10. Jess Says:

    As a TR fan, I will follow his example and not say anything bad about her.

    If he can do it when he would have the most reasons to badmouth her, I can too.

  11. Zephyr Says:

    Sorry, McCynic, but you are completely deluded if you believe that garbage you said about others passing judgment on Shonda because of this photograph. It's called having an OPINION. If you don't like it, don't read our comments. The whole "if you don't have anything nice to say..." argument is completely played out and simply untrue. Just because you don't agree with some comments that were made does not at all make your sweeping generalizations ("cowardly and pathetic") true. In all honesty I have absolutely NO problem saying what I think in a situation where I am not speaking anonymously as you have ignorantly claimed. If you wanted to know what I thought of that picture in real life I'd say the same thing: Shonda looks creepy. Just because you don't like what some people have to say does not warrant you getting your back up and acting all high and mighty. The only thing that's "pathetic" is your seeming inability to stomach the fact that people have opinions that differ from yours.

  12. MM Says:

    I'm not Caroline, but I did meet TR.

    He's such a sweetie pie. He signed me an autograph.

    I never met Shonda.

    I did read her interviews and I must say she does come off looking a bit arrogant at times and out of touch with the fans.

    In her podcasts, she comes off as incredibly shallow. She keeps going on about how hot the actors are.

    I find it interesting she calls Alex hot all the time and have other characters mention it. Derek is McDreamy. Mark is McSteamy, and george? She had him called an ordinary-looking guy.

    And George always ended up being dumped for the hot bad boys.

    The other guys looked down at him like he wasn't worthy of Callie and Izzie and they were too beautiful for him.

    She constantly belittled George on the show,as if a guy wasn't worth anything if he didn't have a model's body and didn't measure 6 feet tall.

    That,s what she seems to be saying.

    That hot guys should get the girls just because they look hot and that they automatically are going to be better in bed.

    George had two women cry in bed with him.

    For her, love is just about looks and sex. George and Izzie had a real connection, true love and great chemistry, and she ridiculed the thought of model Izzie ever being able to be in love with him, and then immediately put her with the supposedly hotter-looking Alex, even though Izzie didn't have the same connection with him.

    I don't know. Someone who's that shallow and who thinks nice cute guys don't deserve love and are inferior to the hot bad boys can't be that good a person, can she?

    She seems pretty twisted and shallow to me just by the way she treated George and the way she treated Brooke, replacing her with a prettier model.

    I think actions speak louder than words sometimes and her actions in both cases say a lot about her.

    Then there is also the fact she cried when she had to fire Isiah and she defended him. She didn't think him using the f word with TR was anything to be mad about. I'm pretty sure she didn't cry when TR left.

  13. McCynic Says:

    Caroline - I realize a lot of people hate her. My point is that no one knows her, or any of them. People on this board have a disturbing inability to distinguish real life from tv fantasy and a bizarre gullibility for the media empire that depends on the slanderous gossip of pop culture icons, regardless of whether it is true. Do you know her at all? Have you met her? Have you met TRK? Do you know anything about any of these people and their lives? I've heard that most of them laugh at the rumours. I'm not justifying anyone. I'm realistic to know that I don't have a clue what was going on there, and I don't know any of these people or anything about them.

    TR isn't helped? He's doing Broadway. I realize most think he'll never amount to what he would have on GA, but that depends on what your definition of success is. If success is happiness and fulfillment, it might not mean fame and fortune. Besides, the guy probably made more than enough $$$ by this point to compensate for income foregone.

  14. Corinne Says:

    Chandra looks amazing. Shonda looks like The Joker. I can't stand that woman!

  15. Caroline Says:

    I am just wondering if Shonda will go to support TR at his show too. I guess not, as she hates him and all.

    The woman looks like a nuts, which she is.

    For the record, not only GI fans hate her. I'd say a lot of the MerDer, Mallie fans are not that fond of her either, not to mention the Brooke fans.

    She's just not a likable person.

    Since Shonda doesn't like nice people (with the bad guys winning all the time in her show and her liking IW over TR), you'd think Shonda would like us.

    Being nice sure didn't help TR at all did it? Quite the contrary!

  16. juli Says:

    Shonda is a very successful tv producer who has used her brains to achieve her success. I can't believe that her looks were that important. Surely she is like the majority of us, a woman with a few extra pounds of weight. If she was in the buisness of making her way through life based on her looks she would surely be an actress! To be as successful as Shonda is , as a woman, all power to her. I also have to say I haven't liked the way George was marginalised as a character either, but sadly it's too late to repair that now

  17. Dimples61 Says:

    Now Cynic did u just give me a little speech about calling names not to long ago? LOL!!! Just kidding!!! You go girl!!!! Get em....LOL!!!

  18. McCynic Says:

    Wow - I gotta say, what a pathetic lot of people you are. Judging someone based on their physical appearance - calling them fat, creepy, etc. You didn't have parents who taught you if you don't have anything nice to say...? And you all hate her so much? She created the freakin' show that you watch faithfully every week (I know, I know, there's a lot of you who ONLY watch for George and Izzie, which strikes me as odd, since you like how nice and sweet they are, while you are all clearly NOT!) It's a photograph, for crying out loud.

    And can I add cowardly to pathetic? Because let's face it, you only say stuff like this from safely and anonymously behind your monitor. Cowardly and pathetic about sums it up.

  19. Zephyr Says:

    LOL

    I think this pic finally gives us a real glimpse of the demented personality that Shonda Rhimes has. That creepy smile on her face is trying to say something, but I'm not even sure I want to know what it is...

    And yeah, she's also put on more weight and it amplifies the creepiness somehow (no offense to overweight people)..

  20. guest Says:

    yeah i did say shonda..
    chandra looks great, the part for her in chicago is perfect! i've seen chicago not with her but it is a really good part for her!
    shondas face though is really like creepy

  21. Nina Says:

    shonda looks creepy and extremely fat. I didn't know she was so fat.

  22. !greys Says:

    he said shonda...and she DOES look creepy.

  23. Greysaholic Says:

    Why creepy @guest. lol.

    I think she looks very pretty and friendy.
    Our lovely Chandra, she's a very nice person I think.

    @guest: or did you mean shonda??

  24. guest Says:

    shonda looks creepy lol

« Previous
1 2

Leave a Comment

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.

Name:

E-Mail:

Remember My Info

Your Comments
No need for HTML formatting, we insert line breaks. Allowed tags: <b> <i> <a>

Login Box

Follow Us!

Keep up with Grey's Anatomy Insider on