were still in season 4 we dont know when seasonn 5 will begin
ex fan Says:
January 16th, 2008 10:58 AM
DEAR McCRITIC..
about this
"McCritic: Derek told Meredith he wanted to marry her. Derek told Meredith he'd wait, but would also keep options open in case someone more committed came along. Derek broke things off with Rose (Lauren Stamile) the instant Meredith wanted to be exclusive. So can anyone tell me what he did wrong?"
Is it believable? Derek forgot to talk about the kiss like he forgot to talk about his wife.
WRONG!
Mina Says:
January 16th, 2008 11:06 AM
All I want is George and Izzie togetehr, waited since season 1 for it. First of all Shonda puts them togetehr the worstw ay as he is married, but I tolerated it because I loved them so much and thought after all the pining and torture, we would get some pay-off. But no, what do we get? One episode of happiness followed by the no-chemistry episode which felt like the biggest slap in the face. Does she think the Gizzie fans are idiots, that we have forgotten their hot, hot kiss last season, that we do not see the amazing chemistry in all their couple scenes? It is pretty obvious she got scared of the haters and like a coward submitted to them, but I can tell her the thousands and thousands of Gizzzie fans will not forgive her for it.
nan-evy Says:
January 17th, 2008 12:28 AM
Happy belated birthday Patrick!!!!!!!!!!
Maddie Says:
January 17th, 2008 9:01 AM
omg!!! i agree with Mina so much. i wanna kiss you on the cheek!! All you Gizzie fans out there don't give up!!! although i know we all got a huge gigantic slap on the face when Gizzie broke up so suddenly in my opinion just because of stupid timing??!! shonda we are all intelligent ppl who deserve a better love story than tht!! i agree that george and izzie had amazing chemistry as Lovers and friends. the only reason i keep religiously watching Greys was because of Gizzie. and now since the writers saw it fit to break those two apart and dump alex into the picture, i don't see any possible reason i would like to watch Greys anymore!! It's so frustrating and unrealistic in so many ways..in terms of the relationships produced!! and how they are turn out...so depressing shonda! Gizzie was perfect together and submission to the Haters wasn't a good idea at all. It ruined everything us Gizzie fans hoped and longed for since season 3! Give us George and izzie again...they were the best on screen couple Greys has seen i ages...and if they put alex with izzie i think i will puke!! literally. he was just a sex toy for her...so shallow and fake. George is real...and he truly Loves her!! COME on!!! Fight for Gizzie n the rite for a happy ending.
Gizzie Forever!!!
Aubrey Says:
January 17th, 2008 5:26 PM
Maddie, I love you, we Gizzie fans cannot give up hope but I am with you as long as Gizzie is not put back together, I will not watch especially if the pukeworthy Alex and Izzie are put back together, watching them mate like disgusting animals was bad enough in season 2, after seeing the beautiful love between george and Izzie, it would be intolerable. Shonda must think the Gizzie fans are idiots or the fans in general. Both fans and haters know Shonda dropped Gizzie for only one reason: she was afraid of the haters's backlash. Well I have news for ehr: the abcklash from the Gizzie fans she so callously ignored will be much worse to bear.
Hayley Says:
January 17th, 2008 9:33 PM
I want George and Izzie together, please no Alex and Izzie hell again! And no George and Callie or George and Lexie. George and Izzie, they are great!
Hannah Says:
January 18th, 2008 1:59 AM
Amen to that!!! :) I adore Gizzie to death! They are the only right and lovable couple on Greys! they are the perfect couple. and us Gizzie fans will continue fighting for their LOVE! they deserve each other.. not alex and izzie, thts gross! and george and lexie is plain odd and weird *creepy*...George and Izzie are forever! and true love never ends. period.
Okay.....I'm all for the whole MerDer thing, but....Meredith really needs to get her stuff straight. One minute she loves him and wants to be with him and the next minute she hates him. Derek was right when he said that she always finds a way to pull away from him. It's either her issues with commitment, her issues with her mother (which really had nothing to do with their relationship), now its issues with trust. The cycle goes on and on and on. I'll admit that when Lexie first came in and it looked like she was stepping on Mer's territory, I was furious....of course that blew over because she set her sights on Alex. When Derek kissed Rose, I wanted to scream, but.....Mer and Der were actually in some kind of Meredith inspired "grey" area. She has poor Derek so confused about where they're at with the relationship that he has no idea what to do. I don't agree with the fact that he went straight to Rose to ask her to dinner after he had a very intense discussion with Meredith, but I can see why he did. I think he needs to take some time off from the relationship scene instead of jumping into a new one with Rose. I don't believe that MerDer is even close to over and I think Rose is going to get hurt in the crossfire. But then again EVERYONE at Seattle Grace Hospital knows about Mer and Der, so Rose knows what she's getting into. If she really believes that Derek is just going to go along and pretend that he never had anything with Meredith, then she is going to get a rude awakening.
As for Bailey and her marriage issues......Tucker is right to want his wife's attention focused on her family, but he needs to realize that she is the center of everything at that hospital...with being Chief Resident and all. He is a major jerk and needs a reality check. I think it really boils down to the fact that he's tired of being a stay at home dad. He should have thought of that before he agreed to the arrangements made before little Tuck was even born. Miranda needs someone who appreciates her for who she is and appreciates what she does. BTW....little Tuck is going to be fine.
George and Izzie......I don't think they should have ever crossed the "friendship" line. Thats not to say I think that Alex and Izzie should be together...because I DO NOT....Alex is an egotistical a-hole. George and Izzie may have love for each other but I think that it is more of a friendship love. Izzie is trying to find a "safe" person to have a relationship with and she picked George because she knows that he will never leave her.
Sabrina Says:
January 18th, 2008 6:11 PM
George and Izzie are perfect. george was hardly the safe guy, he was married and Izzie spent months crying over him. Plus, although I love George, he left Olivia because he did not love her enough then he left Callie for the same reason, so Izzie had no reason to think he would not leave her after all he left for 18 days and did not speak to her. And if you noticed, she counted the days he was away and missed him while Mer and Cristina did not miss Burke and Derek. Izzie cried over George almost more than she did over Denny so how was that safe? If she wanted safe she would go for Alex. She is not in love with him and she could have had sex with him like she did before, and dump him without a look back.
Izzie risked ehr reputation, her friends and her job over George, that tells me the love was real.
And the way she kissed him in that elevator was nothing like friendship love.
They love each other, heart and soul, but right now was not the next time. In the end, they are soulmates though and will be together. And the Gizzie fans are not going anywhere.
Carole Says:
January 18th, 2008 7:39 PM
I agree, George and Izzie need to be together.
mel Says:
January 18th, 2008 8:35 PM
My opinion: All the Geroge & Izzie stuff, I'm glad that everyone seems to forget that Callie is potentially pregnant & that marriage is now considered something to throw around! Fine if they stay together, personally I think their on screen chemistry is nothing more then a one night stand and they seem awkward together. BUT I stand by my McDreamy promised to wait for Merideth & she was taking steps forward & to what him being a jerkoff and going on a date that very night! I hope he decides not to pick her up and declares his undying love and insanity to Merideth & we watch them build a long, health relationship....
I'm looking forward to seeing what McSteamy becomes though.... more of McSteamy & Alex -- Ava can come back permenantly and they could have a solid relationship... one that doesn't break up would be nice!
Bonnie Says:
January 18th, 2008 10:47 PM
Callie has shown no signs of being pregnant at all and even she admits their quickie vegas marriage was not a good idea. Not all marriages are meant to last forever especially when you are half crazy with grief over your dead dad when you make the decision. George and Izzie were beautiful and natural and wonderful togetheer (remember that elevator kiss, the cute flirting in episode 4.2 in the hall and in Mer's house, the whole almost nose-kissing, so cute then in 4.6) until Shonda decided to become a coward and sacrifice her writing integrity to please the overvocal Gizzie haters out there (even though Gizzie had as many or more fans). She then did the awful episode 4.7 where they were suppose to be awkward so as to convince us of the no chemistry crap. except I did not buy it and the minute I saw them on the bed when they broke up and he kissed her shoulder and then they danced together, there was no hiding how well they fit together, how beautiful a couple they were and how the chemistry exploded on the screen. Shonda is a coward and she had a gold mine in Gizzie and wasted it. I do not want to watch anymore.
Erica Says:
January 20th, 2008 8:02 AM
George and Izzie are amazing as a couple!! They aren't just friends as obviously shown throughout all the episodes from s3 n s4..they LOVE each other so so much. and it's clearly affecting them because they are meant to be. Izzie and George shared such a wonderful moment in the linen closet, it was still my most romantic moment on Greys. And the elevator kiss was so HOT...it was not friendship love. As clearly shown...they said their "i love yous" and izzie did cry and fought for george even if it was against her principles. that show how much she cares and Loves him. george isn't anywhere near safe...he is a lil dangerous and it took a huge leap of faith for izzie to confess her feelings to a married man. :) Gizzie are soulmates and shonda shall nvr tear tht love apart, even with stupid alex and lexie combo she gave us. argh. We gizzie fans will continue to fight for Gizzie's Love to come true and live a happy ending together!!
Lauren Says:
January 20th, 2008 12:59 PM
mel- i totally agree with u they should bring back ava for good and have alex and her stay together and we definitely need to see more of alex and mcsteamy i feel like we know nothing about their pasts and its annoying like the show isnt just about mer and der even though there great, there are other characters
1. no, christina's not a robot, she's just pushing all her feelings/emotions into her work right now, now that burke left her. she doesn't want to get distracted, so she's focusing on her job more than ever.
2. izzie + alex = so cute! i've been wanting to see them get together. i mean, george was ok for a while, but come on, look how much trouble they caused! (especially with callie and george's mom.) Izzex should happen. they should try it out.
3. i agree with McCritic on this one. miranda's gonna have to tone down the work bit. but does that even seem possible?
4. possibly. you never know, next thing you know, lexie will be the new girl in his life. just like callie, izzie, etc. he's got a habit of switching girls around, don't you think?
January 16th, 2008 6:33 AM
were still in season 4 we dont know when seasonn 5 will begin
January 16th, 2008 10:58 AM
DEAR McCRITIC..
about this
"McCritic: Derek told Meredith he wanted to marry her. Derek told Meredith he'd wait, but would also keep options open in case someone more committed came along. Derek broke things off with Rose (Lauren Stamile) the instant Meredith wanted to be exclusive. So can anyone tell me what he did wrong?"
Is it believable? Derek forgot to talk about the kiss like he forgot to talk about his wife.
WRONG!
January 16th, 2008 11:06 AM
All I want is George and Izzie togetehr, waited since season 1 for it. First of all Shonda puts them togetehr the worstw ay as he is married, but I tolerated it because I loved them so much and thought after all the pining and torture, we would get some pay-off. But no, what do we get? One episode of happiness followed by the no-chemistry episode which felt like the biggest slap in the face. Does she think the Gizzie fans are idiots, that we have forgotten their hot, hot kiss last season, that we do not see the amazing chemistry in all their couple scenes? It is pretty obvious she got scared of the haters and like a coward submitted to them, but I can tell her the thousands and thousands of Gizzzie fans will not forgive her for it.
January 17th, 2008 12:28 AM
Happy belated birthday Patrick!!!!!!!!!!
January 17th, 2008 9:01 AM
omg!!! i agree with Mina so much. i wanna kiss you on the cheek!! All you Gizzie fans out there don't give up!!! although i know we all got a huge gigantic slap on the face when Gizzie broke up so suddenly in my opinion just because of stupid timing??!! shonda we are all intelligent ppl who deserve a better love story than tht!! i agree that george and izzie had amazing chemistry as Lovers and friends. the only reason i keep religiously watching Greys was because of Gizzie. and now since the writers saw it fit to break those two apart and dump alex into the picture, i don't see any possible reason i would like to watch Greys anymore!! It's so frustrating and unrealistic in so many ways..in terms of the relationships produced!! and how they are turn out...so depressing shonda! Gizzie was perfect together and submission to the Haters wasn't a good idea at all. It ruined everything us Gizzie fans hoped and longed for since season 3! Give us George and izzie again...they were the best on screen couple Greys has seen i ages...and if they put alex with izzie i think i will puke!! literally. he was just a sex toy for her...so shallow and fake. George is real...and he truly Loves her!! COME on!!! Fight for Gizzie n the rite for a happy ending.
Gizzie Forever!!!
January 17th, 2008 5:26 PM
Maddie, I love you, we Gizzie fans cannot give up hope but I am with you as long as Gizzie is not put back together, I will not watch especially if the pukeworthy Alex and Izzie are put back together, watching them mate like disgusting animals was bad enough in season 2, after seeing the beautiful love between george and Izzie, it would be intolerable. Shonda must think the Gizzie fans are idiots or the fans in general. Both fans and haters know Shonda dropped Gizzie for only one reason: she was afraid of the haters's backlash. Well I have news for ehr: the abcklash from the Gizzie fans she so callously ignored will be much worse to bear.
January 17th, 2008 9:33 PM
I want George and Izzie together, please no Alex and Izzie hell again! And no George and Callie or George and Lexie. George and Izzie, they are great!
January 18th, 2008 1:59 AM
Amen to that!!! :) I adore Gizzie to death! They are the only right and lovable couple on Greys! they are the perfect couple. and us Gizzie fans will continue fighting for their LOVE! they deserve each other.. not alex and izzie, thts gross! and george and lexie is plain odd and weird *creepy*...George and Izzie are forever! and true love never ends. period.
January 18th, 2008 11:09 AM
Okay.....I'm all for the whole MerDer thing, but....Meredith really needs to get her stuff straight. One minute she loves him and wants to be with him and the next minute she hates him. Derek was right when he said that she always finds a way to pull away from him. It's either her issues with commitment, her issues with her mother (which really had nothing to do with their relationship), now its issues with trust. The cycle goes on and on and on. I'll admit that when Lexie first came in and it looked like she was stepping on Mer's territory, I was furious....of course that blew over because she set her sights on Alex. When Derek kissed Rose, I wanted to scream, but.....Mer and Der were actually in some kind of Meredith inspired "grey" area. She has poor Derek so confused about where they're at with the relationship that he has no idea what to do. I don't agree with the fact that he went straight to Rose to ask her to dinner after he had a very intense discussion with Meredith, but I can see why he did. I think he needs to take some time off from the relationship scene instead of jumping into a new one with Rose. I don't believe that MerDer is even close to over and I think Rose is going to get hurt in the crossfire. But then again EVERYONE at Seattle Grace Hospital knows about Mer and Der, so Rose knows what she's getting into. If she really believes that Derek is just going to go along and pretend that he never had anything with Meredith, then she is going to get a rude awakening.
As for Bailey and her marriage issues......Tucker is right to want his wife's attention focused on her family, but he needs to realize that she is the center of everything at that hospital...with being Chief Resident and all. He is a major jerk and needs a reality check. I think it really boils down to the fact that he's tired of being a stay at home dad. He should have thought of that before he agreed to the arrangements made before little Tuck was even born. Miranda needs someone who appreciates her for who she is and appreciates what she does. BTW....little Tuck is going to be fine.
George and Izzie......I don't think they should have ever crossed the "friendship" line. Thats not to say I think that Alex and Izzie should be together...because I DO NOT....Alex is an egotistical a-hole. George and Izzie may have love for each other but I think that it is more of a friendship love. Izzie is trying to find a "safe" person to have a relationship with and she picked George because she knows that he will never leave her.
January 18th, 2008 6:11 PM
George and Izzie are perfect. george was hardly the safe guy, he was married and Izzie spent months crying over him. Plus, although I love George, he left Olivia because he did not love her enough then he left Callie for the same reason, so Izzie had no reason to think he would not leave her after all he left for 18 days and did not speak to her. And if you noticed, she counted the days he was away and missed him while Mer and Cristina did not miss Burke and Derek. Izzie cried over George almost more than she did over Denny so how was that safe? If she wanted safe she would go for Alex. She is not in love with him and she could have had sex with him like she did before, and dump him without a look back.
Izzie risked ehr reputation, her friends and her job over George, that tells me the love was real.
And the way she kissed him in that elevator was nothing like friendship love.
They love each other, heart and soul, but right now was not the next time. In the end, they are soulmates though and will be together. And the Gizzie fans are not going anywhere.
January 18th, 2008 7:39 PM
I agree, George and Izzie need to be together.
January 18th, 2008 8:35 PM
My opinion: All the Geroge & Izzie stuff, I'm glad that everyone seems to forget that Callie is potentially pregnant & that marriage is now considered something to throw around! Fine if they stay together, personally I think their on screen chemistry is nothing more then a one night stand and they seem awkward together. BUT I stand by my McDreamy promised to wait for Merideth & she was taking steps forward & to what him being a jerkoff and going on a date that very night! I hope he decides not to pick her up and declares his undying love and insanity to Merideth & we watch them build a long, health relationship....
I'm looking forward to seeing what McSteamy becomes though.... more of McSteamy & Alex -- Ava can come back permenantly and they could have a solid relationship... one that doesn't break up would be nice!
January 18th, 2008 10:47 PM
Callie has shown no signs of being pregnant at all and even she admits their quickie vegas marriage was not a good idea. Not all marriages are meant to last forever especially when you are half crazy with grief over your dead dad when you make the decision. George and Izzie were beautiful and natural and wonderful togetheer (remember that elevator kiss, the cute flirting in episode 4.2 in the hall and in Mer's house, the whole almost nose-kissing, so cute then in 4.6) until Shonda decided to become a coward and sacrifice her writing integrity to please the overvocal Gizzie haters out there (even though Gizzie had as many or more fans). She then did the awful episode 4.7 where they were suppose to be awkward so as to convince us of the no chemistry crap. except I did not buy it and the minute I saw them on the bed when they broke up and he kissed her shoulder and then they danced together, there was no hiding how well they fit together, how beautiful a couple they were and how the chemistry exploded on the screen. Shonda is a coward and she had a gold mine in Gizzie and wasted it. I do not want to watch anymore.
January 20th, 2008 8:02 AM
George and Izzie are amazing as a couple!! They aren't just friends as obviously shown throughout all the episodes from s3 n s4..they LOVE each other so so much. and it's clearly affecting them because they are meant to be. Izzie and George shared such a wonderful moment in the linen closet, it was still my most romantic moment on Greys. And the elevator kiss was so HOT...it was not friendship love. As clearly shown...they said their "i love yous" and izzie did cry and fought for george even if it was against her principles. that show how much she cares and Loves him. george isn't anywhere near safe...he is a lil dangerous and it took a huge leap of faith for izzie to confess her feelings to a married man. :) Gizzie are soulmates and shonda shall nvr tear tht love apart, even with stupid alex and lexie combo she gave us. argh. We gizzie fans will continue to fight for Gizzie's Love to come true and live a happy ending together!!
January 20th, 2008 12:59 PM
mel- i totally agree with u they should bring back ava for good and have alex and her stay together and we definitely need to see more of alex and mcsteamy i feel like we know nothing about their pasts and its annoying like the show isnt just about mer and der even though there great, there are other characters
February 2nd, 2008 4:13 PM
1. no, christina's not a robot, she's just pushing all her feelings/emotions into her work right now, now that burke left her. she doesn't want to get distracted, so she's focusing on her job more than ever.
2. izzie + alex = so cute! i've been wanting to see them get together. i mean, george was ok for a while, but come on, look how much trouble they caused! (especially with callie and george's mom.) Izzex should happen. they should try it out.
3. i agree with McCritic on this one. miranda's gonna have to tone down the work bit. but does that even seem possible?
4. possibly. you never know, next thing you know, lexie will be the new girl in his life. just like callie, izzie, etc. he's got a habit of switching girls around, don't you think?