I just don't see the passion, the chemistry, the tear-your-clothes-off-but-love-me-tender vibe that Derek and Meredith have, happening with Derek and Rose. Rose is just filler. She will NEVER be to Derek what Meredith is to him. She will bore Derek. She bores me. Meredith and Derek excite the audience. Even when they are just standing side by side in an elevator you can FEEL the chemistry. The writers of this show are dragging this whole thing out WAY too long. Bring back the vibe of seasons 1 & 2 PLEASE!!! I'm begging you. I will not watch Derek and Rose build a house with a white picket fence. It would bore me to tears. The show will just plummet right off that cliff that Derek is building hi s dream house on. If MerDer weren't going to end up together then Derek should have stayed with Addison and Meredith with McVet. That would have at least been plausible. Rose is too bubble gum...BORING!!! TEAM MERDER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sissi Says:
January 11th, 2008 1:05 PM
George and Lexie as friends and roommates would be great, but he and Izzie belong together. I agree with missingburke, Alex may have feelings for Izzie but he was never more than a sexmate for her, she never loved him like she did Denny and George.
Anna Says:
January 11th, 2008 1:15 PM
I will stand anything but please no Alex and Izzie, they were gross to watch together and they only have friendship chemistry. Izzie is in love with George and george is in love with her. Once they get over the guilt of hurting Callie, I can see them working their way back to each other down the road. They need to be together!
heather Says:
January 11th, 2008 1:15 PM
mmmm
merder for sureeeee.
Shonda needs to get her head back on..
because this makes me not want to watch it
. . . :]
Gizzieislove Says:
January 11th, 2008 1:27 PM
Team Meredith for sure. I love she and Derek but he needs to earn her trust.
Also totally team George and Izzie and against Alex and Izzie and do not want george and Lexie as more than friends, though I do really love their friendship and glad the show is making them roommies.
Amber Says:
January 11th, 2008 1:48 PM
I loved this episode.
I am totaly for MerDer.......I believe their relationship is not over yet. I am not sure about this Rose thing.....I agree she is boring.
George and Lexi roommates, I like the ideal but how will izzie and callie feel about that one?
Dr Bailey, I felt for her. I cried when her baby was in that bed, but relived when they said he was going to be okay.
I think that Izzie and George should keep their mouths shut, they always get themselves deeper into things.
Back to Mer and Der I love these characters. I think that when they both go and "FIND" themselves they will both know that they can't live without eachother. (I hope)
Gigi Says:
January 11th, 2008 2:02 PM
Team Gizzie all the way! I like Derek and Rose, and want Mer to find a hot guy of her own.
Felicia Says:
January 11th, 2008 2:32 PM
It's amazing looking over so many sites that Derek and Meredith belong together. Rose must think she can make Derek forget Meredith little does she know it won't happen. They love each other to much and no matter how frustrated they get with each other they always find their way back. I like the idea of George and Lexie sharing an apartment. I like the way they bonded as friends right off the bat. The problem is Izzie really doesn't like to share George with anyone. Those are the two things I want the most MerDer in a happy loving relationship and that special bond Gizzie had as bestfriends. I hope the writers take this extra long break to clear their heads and think about season 5. I don't think we can get back what they had in season 1&2 but they can make season 5 better without empty promises.
Mia Says:
January 11th, 2008 2:39 PM
I think that with George learing to take care of himself, it will make it easier for him and Izzie to get back together. Like he said, he doens't know who he is anymore. He wants to get back to being "George."
Loved how Izzie said that she fell in love with him. Let's keep hope alive my fellow Gizzie fans.
Gabriella Says:
January 11th, 2008 2:46 PM
Hey Mia, I am keeping hope, I loved it when Izzie said she had not even realized she was in love with him, that she was in love with him before the drunken hook-up. That made me squee. Gizzie forever! I am NEVER giving up on them!
die_lexie_grey Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:10 PM
Always and forever, team Meredith!
What he did wrong? Seriously? Seriously? Where do I start? Let´s see... He was married, and lied about it. She chose Addison, then he wanted Meredith back when she was dating Finn and trying to move along. He called her a whore because HE was angry and totally jelous. He stalked her until they had sex in the exam room. He makes her choose, and before she does, he abandons her for the second time. When she chose him anyway, he stayed away for a while. When she´s down because of her family issues (her mother told her she shouldn´t have had her, her mother dies, her fake mommy dies, her father slaps her and blames her for Susan´s death, etc) and he abandons her after her near death experience because "he cannot breathe for her", then he says he wants to marry her BUT pressures her once again telling her that he is not necesarilly going to wait for her, then he dates this Rose and kisses her and is not being totally honest with Meredith...
Did I forget something? Probably. That happens to me all the time.
So, to me, the choice is easy. I choose Meredith. Derek may be McDreamy, but he is an asshole. A total jerk. He is the one who pushed her away in the first place, and now he complains about her lack of commitment?
Please! No wonder Meredith has abandonment issues and is not very trusting...
But I still want them together forever...
And Izzie and Alex work fine, but George and Lexie? No way... As for McSteamy, I hope Callie gets lucky. And finally, Miranda deserves to be with a man who undestands her, and who can deal with a very commited woman, to her family and to her career as well.
We can´t forget that she tries to make things work. Her situatios is nothing like Richard´s, who had an affair, stayed with his wife instead of having a real relationship with the love of his life and avoided going home like the plague.
pamela Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:31 PM
I like to see mer with another hot man. der is a freaking asshole
Meggles the great Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:33 PM
Team Meredith. I totally seen her point as to why she can't trust him. It's not digging up old stuff, she's making a point. Derek has a tendancy of covering up things that would turn Meredith off (the wife, the other woman) and he thinks she has trust issues. Has anyone else noticed that she only really has trust issues with him? She trusts Christina, Izzie, George, Alex, hell, even MARK more then Derek. And I can't say I blame them.
Honestly, I would have loved to see Lexie move in with Meredith somehow, only so they could get to know each other better, as they are clearly trying. But as long as there isn't any romance between George and Lexie, it should be ok.
And can I say how much I love Dr. Hahn? She's so cool, and I love how she told Mark he was too pretty. They'll hook up I'm sure, but for now, the flirting is cute.
I love how this season is all friendships. It's the kind of "makes you wanna call your best friend" feeling that I missed from the first 2 seasons of Grey's
iloveEllenPompeo Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:37 PM
TEAM MEREDITH ALL THE WAY!!! DEREK is a jerk he dumped the poor thing he did something wrong with that slutty nurse rose!!!! Meredith did nothing wrong (in this season)
Rachel Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:40 PM
i agree completely, 100%, with kathy. Meredith and Derek need to get over their problems and get back to being the couple they were in season 1.
And Derek needs to get rid of Rose.... a few hours before he asked her out he told her they were just friends and the kiss meant nothing. what's up with that?? Derek really wants to build that dream house for him and Meredith ...so he should make some kind of an apology so they can get back to their relationship..
Lauren Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:47 PM
ok meredith and derek are so annoying ! neither team for me!!! there so annoying especially meredith and her commitment issues.. and when she says she cant trust him and thats it YEAH LIKE THATS THE MAIN PROBLEM! for cyring out loud SHE'S the problem!
george and lexie- thats just weird if there roomates
hahn and sloan- TOTALLY MADE THE ENDING CAUSE OTHERWISE I DIDN'T LIKE THE ENDING but that whole your too pretty and we would be TOO good together was just too cute
alex and izzie- i always loved them together but just figured something was gonna happen between ava and alex and i loved them but i know thats not gonna happen anymore
MARK & SLOAN and IZZIE & ALEX all the way !!!!
(bailey im disappointed they are most likely getting divorced and i was very disappointed with the ending they said there was gonna be so many cliffhangers and there werent!)
SCGreysFan Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:50 PM
It was great to see Cristina's emotional & caring side last night when she held Tuck's hand and remained there even after being offered time at the operatiing table.
Although, it was sad to see the end of MerDer - just depressing as they were a dream in Season1 - like so many comments have said.
And here's the thing, Derek is so far from being McDreamy now (hello...asking Rose out moments after he breaks up with Mer - the woman he dragged out of the water, the woman he wanted to marry, the love of his life!!!), that even if he & Mer do work things out and build a real relationship I don't know if he'll ever really be McDreamy again.
iloveEllenPompeo Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:54 PM
merediths not annoying lauren!!!!!!!!!
kaybee Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:58 PM
I can not belive George! Being a roommate with Lexie No he is with izzie!
Or at least he will be, I really want izzie to be pregnat, george said it was the timing not the chemistry. They could not be together because noone around them wanted them to be together. I izzie were pregnat that would do a 180. Noone would want george to leave his baby, and Mrs. O'Malley's baby clothes could go to good use, she can't be mad with a grandchild. George and izzie can get a house together instead of george and lexie renting an apartment. George still is the one that bailey named her baby after, he only made one mistake, marry callie, him and izzie are ment to be!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kaybee Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:59 PM
Who wants more GIZZIE!?!
McWorried Says:
January 11th, 2008 3:59 PM
MerDer have chemistry. This season has not been so good for them but it will happen. They love each other very much! Come on we have struggled with the two of them enough. Let them be happy together. The McThorny (Rose) thing ~ maybe she would be a good match with McVet. Please don't break MerDer.
Frank Says:
January 11th, 2008 4:07 PM
I want more Gizzie. I think it is the guilt and the timing that tripped them up because it is obvious they are in love with each other and when they danced last week, they had tons of romantic chemistry and who can forget that hot elevator kiss and the flirting in the hall at the beginning of the season? So much sexual tension! George and Lexie would be cute for a fling, but not more, and Alex and Izzie are MCVOMIT.
GEORGE AND IZZIE BELONG TOGETHER!
Daniella Says:
January 11th, 2008 4:10 PM
Please please please no Alex and Izzie, I had to endure their disgusting sex scenes all through season 2 which sent me barfing to the bathroom more often than I liked, do not go back there again. They are gross and disgusting. I also see no chemistry there.
I don't want George and Lexie either, but at least they have some chemistry and could make a cute couple, not a gross slimy one like Lexzie.
But Shonda, Izzie and George NEED to be together!
I loved that Gizzie fans won the poll here.
Maria Says:
January 11th, 2008 4:18 PM
Boo to Alex and Izzie and Mark and Sloan. Yay for George and Izzie and Mark and Callie! And Meredith is not annoying!
Hahn can go, I hate her!
Alex has two women, he does not need a third, maybe he should be alone for a while.
Lexie and George I love as friends and glad this is being explored, but the only woman George should be with is Izzie and vice-versa.
TeamDerek Says:
January 11th, 2008 4:24 PM
TEAM DEREK ALL THE WAY!!! I think Derek and Rose are a good couple, and way r u people so mad at Rose what did she do wrong she is single and Derek was single when they kiss!!!
January 11th, 2008 12:46 PM
I just don't see the passion, the chemistry, the tear-your-clothes-off-but-love-me-tender vibe that Derek and Meredith have, happening with Derek and Rose. Rose is just filler. She will NEVER be to Derek what Meredith is to him. She will bore Derek. She bores me. Meredith and Derek excite the audience. Even when they are just standing side by side in an elevator you can FEEL the chemistry. The writers of this show are dragging this whole thing out WAY too long. Bring back the vibe of seasons 1 & 2 PLEASE!!! I'm begging you. I will not watch Derek and Rose build a house with a white picket fence. It would bore me to tears. The show will just plummet right off that cliff that Derek is building hi s dream house on. If MerDer weren't going to end up together then Derek should have stayed with Addison and Meredith with McVet. That would have at least been plausible. Rose is too bubble gum...BORING!!! TEAM MERDER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
January 11th, 2008 1:05 PM
George and Lexie as friends and roommates would be great, but he and Izzie belong together. I agree with missingburke, Alex may have feelings for Izzie but he was never more than a sexmate for her, she never loved him like she did Denny and George.
January 11th, 2008 1:15 PM
I will stand anything but please no Alex and Izzie, they were gross to watch together and they only have friendship chemistry. Izzie is in love with George and george is in love with her. Once they get over the guilt of hurting Callie, I can see them working their way back to each other down the road. They need to be together!
January 11th, 2008 1:15 PM
mmmm
merder for sureeeee.
Shonda needs to get her head back on..
because this makes me not want to watch it
. . . :]
January 11th, 2008 1:27 PM
Team Meredith for sure. I love she and Derek but he needs to earn her trust.
Also totally team George and Izzie and against Alex and Izzie and do not want george and Lexie as more than friends, though I do really love their friendship and glad the show is making them roommies.
January 11th, 2008 1:48 PM
I loved this episode.
I am totaly for MerDer.......I believe their relationship is not over yet. I am not sure about this Rose thing.....I agree she is boring.
George and Lexi roommates, I like the ideal but how will izzie and callie feel about that one?
Dr Bailey, I felt for her. I cried when her baby was in that bed, but relived when they said he was going to be okay.
I think that Izzie and George should keep their mouths shut, they always get themselves deeper into things.
Back to Mer and Der I love these characters. I think that when they both go and "FIND" themselves they will both know that they can't live without eachother. (I hope)
January 11th, 2008 2:02 PM
Team Gizzie all the way! I like Derek and Rose, and want Mer to find a hot guy of her own.
January 11th, 2008 2:32 PM
It's amazing looking over so many sites that Derek and Meredith belong together. Rose must think she can make Derek forget Meredith little does she know it won't happen. They love each other to much and no matter how frustrated they get with each other they always find their way back. I like the idea of George and Lexie sharing an apartment. I like the way they bonded as friends right off the bat. The problem is Izzie really doesn't like to share George with anyone. Those are the two things I want the most MerDer in a happy loving relationship and that special bond Gizzie had as bestfriends. I hope the writers take this extra long break to clear their heads and think about season 5. I don't think we can get back what they had in season 1&2 but they can make season 5 better without empty promises.
January 11th, 2008 2:39 PM
I think that with George learing to take care of himself, it will make it easier for him and Izzie to get back together. Like he said, he doens't know who he is anymore. He wants to get back to being "George."
Loved how Izzie said that she fell in love with him. Let's keep hope alive my fellow Gizzie fans.
January 11th, 2008 2:46 PM
Hey Mia, I am keeping hope, I loved it when Izzie said she had not even realized she was in love with him, that she was in love with him before the drunken hook-up. That made me squee. Gizzie forever! I am NEVER giving up on them!
January 11th, 2008 3:10 PM
Always and forever, team Meredith!
What he did wrong? Seriously? Seriously? Where do I start? Let´s see... He was married, and lied about it. She chose Addison, then he wanted Meredith back when she was dating Finn and trying to move along. He called her a whore because HE was angry and totally jelous. He stalked her until they had sex in the exam room. He makes her choose, and before she does, he abandons her for the second time. When she chose him anyway, he stayed away for a while. When she´s down because of her family issues (her mother told her she shouldn´t have had her, her mother dies, her fake mommy dies, her father slaps her and blames her for Susan´s death, etc) and he abandons her after her near death experience because "he cannot breathe for her", then he says he wants to marry her BUT pressures her once again telling her that he is not necesarilly going to wait for her, then he dates this Rose and kisses her and is not being totally honest with Meredith...
Did I forget something? Probably. That happens to me all the time.
So, to me, the choice is easy. I choose Meredith. Derek may be McDreamy, but he is an asshole. A total jerk. He is the one who pushed her away in the first place, and now he complains about her lack of commitment?
Please! No wonder Meredith has abandonment issues and is not very trusting...
But I still want them together forever...
And Izzie and Alex work fine, but George and Lexie? No way... As for McSteamy, I hope Callie gets lucky. And finally, Miranda deserves to be with a man who undestands her, and who can deal with a very commited woman, to her family and to her career as well.
We can´t forget that she tries to make things work. Her situatios is nothing like Richard´s, who had an affair, stayed with his wife instead of having a real relationship with the love of his life and avoided going home like the plague.
January 11th, 2008 3:31 PM
I like to see mer with another hot man. der is a freaking asshole
January 11th, 2008 3:33 PM
Team Meredith. I totally seen her point as to why she can't trust him. It's not digging up old stuff, she's making a point. Derek has a tendancy of covering up things that would turn Meredith off (the wife, the other woman) and he thinks she has trust issues. Has anyone else noticed that she only really has trust issues with him? She trusts Christina, Izzie, George, Alex, hell, even MARK more then Derek. And I can't say I blame them.
Honestly, I would have loved to see Lexie move in with Meredith somehow, only so they could get to know each other better, as they are clearly trying. But as long as there isn't any romance between George and Lexie, it should be ok.
And can I say how much I love Dr. Hahn? She's so cool, and I love how she told Mark he was too pretty. They'll hook up I'm sure, but for now, the flirting is cute.
I love how this season is all friendships. It's the kind of "makes you wanna call your best friend" feeling that I missed from the first 2 seasons of Grey's
January 11th, 2008 3:37 PM
TEAM MEREDITH ALL THE WAY!!! DEREK is a jerk he dumped the poor thing he did something wrong with that slutty nurse rose!!!! Meredith did nothing wrong (in this season)
January 11th, 2008 3:40 PM
i agree completely, 100%, with kathy. Meredith and Derek need to get over their problems and get back to being the couple they were in season 1.
And Derek needs to get rid of Rose.... a few hours before he asked her out he told her they were just friends and the kiss meant nothing. what's up with that?? Derek really wants to build that dream house for him and Meredith ...so he should make some kind of an apology so they can get back to their relationship..
January 11th, 2008 3:47 PM
ok meredith and derek are so annoying ! neither team for me!!! there so annoying especially meredith and her commitment issues.. and when she says she cant trust him and thats it YEAH LIKE THATS THE MAIN PROBLEM! for cyring out loud SHE'S the problem!
george and lexie- thats just weird if there roomates
hahn and sloan- TOTALLY MADE THE ENDING CAUSE OTHERWISE I DIDN'T LIKE THE ENDING but that whole your too pretty and we would be TOO good together was just too cute
alex and izzie- i always loved them together but just figured something was gonna happen between ava and alex and i loved them but i know thats not gonna happen anymore
MARK & SLOAN and IZZIE & ALEX all the way !!!!
(bailey im disappointed they are most likely getting divorced and i was very disappointed with the ending they said there was gonna be so many cliffhangers and there werent!)
January 11th, 2008 3:50 PM
It was great to see Cristina's emotional & caring side last night when she held Tuck's hand and remained there even after being offered time at the operatiing table.
Although, it was sad to see the end of MerDer - just depressing as they were a dream in Season1 - like so many comments have said.
And here's the thing, Derek is so far from being McDreamy now (hello...asking Rose out moments after he breaks up with Mer - the woman he dragged out of the water, the woman he wanted to marry, the love of his life!!!), that even if he & Mer do work things out and build a real relationship I don't know if he'll ever really be McDreamy again.
January 11th, 2008 3:54 PM
merediths not annoying lauren!!!!!!!!!
January 11th, 2008 3:58 PM
I can not belive George! Being a roommate with Lexie No he is with izzie!
Or at least he will be, I really want izzie to be pregnat, george said it was the timing not the chemistry. They could not be together because noone around them wanted them to be together. I izzie were pregnat that would do a 180. Noone would want george to leave his baby, and Mrs. O'Malley's baby clothes could go to good use, she can't be mad with a grandchild. George and izzie can get a house together instead of george and lexie renting an apartment. George still is the one that bailey named her baby after, he only made one mistake, marry callie, him and izzie are ment to be!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
January 11th, 2008 3:59 PM
Who wants more GIZZIE!?!
January 11th, 2008 3:59 PM
MerDer have chemistry. This season has not been so good for them but it will happen. They love each other very much! Come on we have struggled with the two of them enough. Let them be happy together. The McThorny (Rose) thing ~ maybe she would be a good match with McVet. Please don't break MerDer.
January 11th, 2008 4:07 PM
I want more Gizzie. I think it is the guilt and the timing that tripped them up because it is obvious they are in love with each other and when they danced last week, they had tons of romantic chemistry and who can forget that hot elevator kiss and the flirting in the hall at the beginning of the season? So much sexual tension! George and Lexie would be cute for a fling, but not more, and Alex and Izzie are MCVOMIT.
GEORGE AND IZZIE BELONG TOGETHER!
January 11th, 2008 4:10 PM
Please please please no Alex and Izzie, I had to endure their disgusting sex scenes all through season 2 which sent me barfing to the bathroom more often than I liked, do not go back there again. They are gross and disgusting. I also see no chemistry there.
I don't want George and Lexie either, but at least they have some chemistry and could make a cute couple, not a gross slimy one like Lexzie.
But Shonda, Izzie and George NEED to be together!
I loved that Gizzie fans won the poll here.
January 11th, 2008 4:18 PM
Boo to Alex and Izzie and Mark and Sloan. Yay for George and Izzie and Mark and Callie! And Meredith is not annoying!
Hahn can go, I hate her!
Alex has two women, he does not need a third, maybe he should be alone for a while.
Lexie and George I love as friends and glad this is being explored, but the only woman George should be with is Izzie and vice-versa.
January 11th, 2008 4:24 PM
TEAM DEREK ALL THE WAY!!! I think Derek and Rose are a good couple, and way r u people so mad at Rose what did she do wrong she is single and Derek was single when they kiss!!!